Thursday, October 6, 2011

Dead Man's Folly by Agatha Christie

64. Dead Man's Folly - an Hercule Poirot mystery
by Agatha Christie
mystery, 1956
Kindle book, 41
first book for R.I.P. VI challenge
finished, 10/3/11

I decided I would include this as one of my choices for the R.I.P. VI challenge,

because other than Ten Little Indians, I think this is the darkest Agatha Christie I have read thus far. I chose it because Ariadne Oliver, the mystery author is in the story. I so enjoyed reading about her in Cards On The Table that I wanted to spend some more reading time in her company. She has been asked to create a mock murder entertainment at a village fête. It should have been a fun endeavor but she has the oddest feeling that she is being manoeuvred in her plans. She calls Poirot and begs, rather demands, that he come to Nasse House, Nassecombe. She can't tell him much on the phone, but the concern in her voice is enough to make him go there immediately. When he arrives, he finds Ariadne eating an apple, as always:
'I knew you'd come,' said Mrs. Oliver cheerfully.
'You could not possibly have known,' said Poirot severely.
'Oh, yes, I did.'
'I still ask myself why I am here.'
'Well, I know the answer. Curiosity.'
Poirot looked at her and his eyes twinkled a little. 'Your famous woman's intuition,' he said, 'has, perhaps, for once not led you too far astray.'
She tells him that she has been hired to 'arrange a murder' - a Murder Hunt as a change from the more familiar Treasure Hunt. She tells Poirot,
'... I think there's something wrong. ... I've felt - more and more - that I was being - oh! - engineered...jockeyed along...Call me a fool if you like, but I can only say that if there was to be a real murder tomorrow instead of a fake one, I shouldn't be surprised.'
'If you know anything at all about writers, you'll know that they can't stand suggestions.'
'That sort of silly suggestion has been made, and then I've flared up, and they've given in, but have just slipped in some quite minor trivial suggestion and because I've made such a stand over the other, I've accepted the triviality without noticing much.'
Poirot immediately understands just what she means - that 'the small minor alteration is really the objective.'

Mrs. Oliver introduces Poirot (and the readers) to all the characters, and tells him all about the clues and solution to the Murder Hunt. The weapons are laid out upon a table: 'a small pistol, a piece of lead piping with a rusty sinister stain on it, a blue bottle labeled Poison, a length of clothesline and a hypodermic syringe,' just as pictured on the above cover of the first American edition of Dead Man's Folly!

On the day of the fête, the somewhat simple-minded wife of the estate owner goes missing, and the pretend murder victim is found literally so. In my reading of Christie's work, this is the first time I have seen a child as a murder victim. Though you may think this a spoiler, it really isn't. Although the death doesn't occur for a while in the book, I think we readers realize right from the start that fiction is going to equal reality in this Murder Hunt. This death is the beginning of why the book is so dark. I wonder if Agatha ever had a child die in any other book. This is a particularly grim aspect as is the missing wife. There is another character whose life story is utterly heartbreaking. Poirot and Oliver cannot lighten the tale. There is no Hastings to bring a sense of sweetness.

The mystery itself was mildly interesting to me, though quite complicated and convoluted. I had to work to keep the names straight. But I believe that every book, every word Agatha Christie wrote is worth reading. And even though this particular story was not my favorite, I did so enjoy the setting. It is a particularly fine one - a big house on 65 acres of woods and fields and water. After I had finished, I read the locale was actually Agatha's beloved Greenway. And coincidentally (?) I just received the book I ordered about her homes, called Agatha Christie At Home by Hilary Macaskill.

This is deserving of its own future book report but for now I will say that if you love Agatha Christie's work, you will love this book. A few people had recommended it to me, and I'm most grateful. I will read it, refer to it, and look through it over and over. Another 'companion' to add to these books I've mentioned so often.

In Agatha Christie At Home I learned that
Greenway had made an appearance in Agatha's fiction before, as Alderbury in Five Little Pigs, but Dead Man's Folly could act as a guidebook for the estate. The surroundings of Nasse House (which even Poirot approves of) described in this book mirror exactly those of Greenway, from the beautiful river view with 'hills of a misty blue in the distance,' which Poirot is invited to admire, to the position of the neighboring youth hostel.
And here is the scene of the crime!


  1. It's been a long time since I've read DEAD MAN'S FOLLY. I think it was the first time I had heard of a murder game. I did not remember that a child died, but she also had a child die in HALLOWEEN PARTY. Ariadne Oliver is in that one too. Coincidence?

    Your resource books look fun.

  2. Isn't that odd about AO in another one with that circumstance. Murder games/evenings/ weekends/dinners are quite common now, aren't they? I never wanted to attend. I guess I thought it might work out like those Civil War reenactments on tv crime shows where someone has a gun with real bullets. I wonder if anyone has ever died at one of those murder things. Would make a good true crime book!

  3. Agatha Christie At Home! That is my kind of book! Just found a photo of myself when I was 18 and I was holding a paperback book. It was Murder On The Orient Express. See, I've always had good taste!
    Love your leaf color... see, I knew you would find some for us!

  4. Are you reading Agatha in any particular order? This one does sound dark. I love (and envy, in a nice way ;>)) your resource library.

  5. Kay, I love that! You oughtta put the pic up on your blog. I'm not sure I had even heard of Agatha at that age. I'm way impressed.

    Sallie, I'm not reading them in any particular order -mostly. I didn't begin reading in order, but then I did for a while. I jump around a bit now. Those companion books are a joy to me.

  6. I love this book. I've lost count of the many times I've read it. It always holds my attention even if I know what's what going in.

    It is so beautifully plotted.

    Loved reading your post as well. And I'm so envious of your beautiful book on Dame Agatha's houses.

  7. Nan, You make me will take me a long time to put a photo of myself on my blog! Also, I looked it up and the movie Murder On The Orient Express came out in 1974, and I think I went to the movies to see it, which means that I already knew the outcome before I read the book? (I was 18 in 1975). Did I want to read the book just because I liked the movie? Curiouser and curiouser! But hey, I'm giving myself a break here, it WAS a long time ago!

  8. Yvette, you ought to get yourself a copy. It is totally worth the money. There are photos of Agatha which are wonderful.

    Kay, you know, I've not even seen the movie or the tv adaptation. I'm hoping to read the book next year, and then do some watching! Thanks for the reminder.

  9. I've been meaning to read more Christie for a while, and haven't read this one - although not your favourite, I would like to read one with Ariadne Oliver in it, and the setting sounds up my street. I wonder if my housemate has it... Thanks for reviewing this, Nan!

  10. I've only two Christie books, and they weren't particularly dark -- this seems like a good choice for RIP!

    These Christie companion books are wonderful - all the back stories and photos really make the author (and her world/inspirations) come alive.

  11. Simon, she's a really great character! I found that she is in these books:
    The Case of the Discontented Soldier - first appearance
    Parker Pyne Investigates
    Cards on the Table - first book
    Mrs McGinty's Dead
    Dead Man's Folly
    The Pale Horse - without Poirot
    Third Girl
    Hallowe'en Party
    Elephants Can Remember

    Dawn, that's just how I feel about these companion books.

  12. I deliberately didn't read your review when you posted it because I was just about to read the book for the first time! I had no idea that Nasse House was based on Greenway; thanks for the info. I have to disagree about the darkness. I find there is something heartless about the way the girl's murder is described.

  13. Amazing, call me madam! I bet you meant 'agree' not 'disagree' - and yes, there was a heartless feel. The girl was made out to be a nothing, as was her poor family.


I'll answer your comments as soon as I possibly can. Please do come back if you've asked a question.
Also, you may comment on any post, no matter how old, and I will see it.